Confessions of a Beauty Skeptic: Nine Years In, I Finally Get What Fenty Beauty Actually Changed
From our previous site: the original author’s perspective is preserved verbatim, including first-person experiences and historical product information. This republication is not a new product test. First published 2026-08-24; migrated October 9, 2026.
I'll say it up front: I was a beauty skeptic with a capital S. When the first collection dropped in September 2017, I filed the whole thing under "celebrity vanity project," rolled my eyes at the launch-week frenzy, and went back to my trusty drugstore routine. Nine years and one completely rebuilt makeup bag later, I'm writing this in late August 2026 as a reluctant — and slightly annoyed — convert. Annoyed because Fenty Beauty proved me wrong on every single count.
The Argument I Lost Back in 2017
Here's what I didn't understand back then: for millions of makeup wearers, foundation shopping wasn't mildly annoying. It was functionally impossible. A friend of mine spent her entire adult life blending two different bottles to approximate a shade the industry simply never bothered to make. Then Fenty Beauty launched with 40 shades of the Pro Filt'r Soft Matte Longwear Foundation, and she posted a photo of her first bottle with a caption I still think about: "they finally made MY color."
The industry came to call it the "Fenty Effect." Time magazine called it one of the Best Inventions of 2017. The balance sheet called it roughly $100 million in the first 40 days. My friend didn't call it anything — she just stopped mixing bottles. That, as it turned out, was the whole pitch: Beauty for All, from Rihanna's own middle name (Robyn Rihanna Fenty), backed by LVMH, and aimed squarely at everyone the beauty counter had trained to settle.
The Skeptic's Scorecard: What Actually Won Me Over
This summer I finally did what I should have done years ago: tested the current lineup properly, with no cherry-picking and no mercy. Herewith, the scorecard — sorted by how wrong I was.
The Foundation That Ended the Debate
The current hero is the Pro Filt'r Fluid Flex Natural Matte Longwear Foundation, a waterproof, transfer-resistant formula in 50 shades that bends and stretches "to every (e)motion." I assumed that was marketing poetry. It is not — it's a literal description of a base that moves when your face moves and never announces itself. The OG Soft Matte and the 50-shade Instant Retouch Concealer round out a complexion family that still has no real rival on depth of range.
The Lip Gloss Now Living in Every Pocket I Own
I called the original Gloss Bomb Universal Lip Luminizer "a trend" in 2017, which aged exactly as well as you'd expect. The word universal is doing real work: sheer-but-visible color, a shimmer engineered to flatter every skin tone, zero stick, and that warm vanilla-caramel scent people describe in the reverent tones usually reserved for bakeries. The family grew up too — the twist-up Gloss Bomb Stix (my current fixation: Black'r Berry), the plumping Gloss Bomb Heat, and the Trace'd Out Waterproof Pencil Lip Liner for when I'm feeling precise.
The Glow I Didn't See Coming
I assumed the cheek category was filler. Then the Killawatt Freestyle Highlighter went from "a whisper" to "a spotlight" in two taps and stayed put through a heatwave, and the Fenty Cheeks Suede Powder Blush in Petal Poppin' delivered the softest flush I've gotten from a powder, period. There's a newer Demi'glow Light-Diffusing Highlighter as well, for anyone who wants the lit-from-within thing without the shimmer.
The Finishers Nobody Applauds Loudly Enough
Unsung heroes, ranked: the Invisimatte Instant Setting + Blotting Powder (blurs shine, zero flashback, phone-camera-proof), the You Mist Makeup-Extending Setting Spray (the reason my 7 a.m. face survived a 9 p.m. dinner), and the edge-cutting Precision Makeup Sponge 100, which I now buy in pairs like a normal person.
A Full Day Without Thinking About My Face
The real test came last week: a 7 a.m. airport run straight into a late-August heatwave, one delayed flight, one client presentation, one dinner that was supposed to be quick and wasn't. Fourteen hours. The base went on with two pumps and a sponge, got one press of powder at midday, and needed exactly one thing by nightfall — more gloss.
And that's when it clicked. The actual product Fenty Beauty sells isn't foundation, and it isn't gloss. It's the silence in your head where the "do I look okay?" loop used to be. I spent fourteen hours thinking about my trip instead of my T-zone. No drugstore base I've ever owned has done that.
The Empire That Outgrew My Makeup Bag
What began as makeup is now a full universe, and — annoyingly — the expansions are good too. Fenty Skin handles the before-and-after (the Dew N Plump Hydrating Face Mist now lives on my desk); the Butta Drop Refillable Whipped Oil Body Cream is the reason my elbows have opinions again; Fenty Hair makes a Homecurl Curl-Defining Cream my wavy-haired self swears by; and the Fenty Eau de Parfum is, depending on who you ask, "warm" or "dangerous." Both are correct.
Who It's Still Not For
A skeptic's column owes you the other side. If your signature look is full-coverage, porcelain-matte and absolutely immovable, the natural-matte finish here may feel too much like skin. The Soft Matte formula needs hydrated skin underneath or it will find your dry patches and relocate there. Hero shades sell out with a speed I can only describe as competitive. And at $16–$48 a piece this sits above drugstore pricing — you're paying prestige-adjacent money for prestige-adjacent performance, cruelty-free formulas included. Fair warning, fairly earned.
The Verdict From a Recovering Skeptic
Nine years in, the case I once dismissed has become the case I make to friends: start with the Fluid Flex Foundation if your base has ever betrayed you, with a Gloss Bomb if it hasn't, or — my own path — with a spite-purchase you have absolutely no intention of keeping. I'll simply note that mine came with three back-ups.
Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. All product images are courtesy of fentybeauty.com.